Pop and Propaganda – Chinese posters and Wang Guangyi

So what’s left of Chairman Mao’s communist legacy in a country that is hurtling into a new capitalist age? How is this being reflected in contemporary Chinese art and design? These questions have been on my mind since going to see the exhibition of Chinese propaganda posters at Gallery TOM in Shibuya. The images, made between the late 1950s to the 1980s, are so arresting, so over the top: people waving guns and flags in the air, striding around, saluting, chests thrust out — this is some serious nation-building being depicted!

Written by Ashley Rawlings
Images of propaganda posters courtesy of Maopost

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-1
Wang Guangyi, ‘Great Criticism: Time’ (2002) (120cm x 200cm)

The strength of their design, as well as their historical worth has not gone unrecognised: the posters on display in this exhibition are all from a private collection. But while they’ve become collector’s items, it’s not to say that they are entirely consigned to history. Seeing this exhibition instantly made me think of Wang Guangyi, the Chinese contemporary artist whose work shows the strongest influence from this design heritage, and so I thought it would be interesting to compare the two.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-2
Unknown Artist, ‘Observe, check and implement everything from the perspective of combat readiness.’ (1966)
chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-3
Wang Guangyi, Great Criticism: Disney — 1999 (200cm x 200cm)

Bold outlines divide the yellow of the foreground from the red background, giving form to striving, workers who thrust their arms into the air. Their faces are filled with determination: they are ready for self-sacrifice for the greater good… or are they? Am I talking about the picture on the left or on the right? In Wang Guangyi’s work, the workers are surrounded by the logos of Western designer names and brands: Coca-Cola, Volvo, Disney, Chanel, Marlboro, Kodak, TIME and Carlsberg. Is this what contemporary China is striving for?

So how does the history of the Cultural Revolution intertwine with Wang Guangyi’s Great Criticism series? Wang was born in 1957, the year before Mao declared a start to the Great Leap Forward (1958–1962) which aimed to bring China’s agriculture and industry up to western levels of production. This period is viewed both within China and elsewhere as something of a disaster, and it was with the aim of reinvigorating the socialist revolution that Mao initiated the Cultural Revolution (1966–1976). Wang Guangyi grew up in the two decades when the propaganda poster thrived.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-4
The exhibition at Gallery TOM
chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-5
Unknown Artist, ‘Chairman Mao is the red sun in our hearts.’ (c. 1975)

One aspect of the poster campaign was to create a cult of personality surrounding Mao. His omnipresent image is the first thing you notice when you go into the exhibition at Gallery TOM. Usually painted in red or warm tones, Mao was portrayed as a noble man of the people, visiting factories and talking with workers and peasants. If the sun isn’t already radiating out from behind him, then it seems to beam out of his very face!

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-6
Mao badges on display at Gallery TOM

The Communist Party employed China’s best artists and designers from before the founding of the People’s Republic to produce the propaganda posters, and for a long time they were very successful. The posters were cheap and easy to produce and the strong visualization of abstract ideas worked well in a country where many people were illiterate at the time. People were also pleased to have more colour to liven up otherwise drab surroundings and the images spread into homes as well as workplaces, journals and magazines.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-7
Unknown Artist, ‘Camping far out in the wilderness forges a revolutionary heart’ (1971)

Wang Guangyi went to art school in 1980: four years after Mao died and just as the Communist Party effectively declared an end to the Cultural Revolution. Deng Xiaoping was opening China up to the West, introducing market reforms which led to a gradual improvement in quality of life. The design of propaganda posters changed in order to reflect this new reality: they no longer had the serious, militaristic feel of the previous decades but took on themes like education and hygiene.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-8
Unknown Artist, ‘Pay attention to food hygiene and improve health levels.’ (1981)
chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-9
Unknown Artist, ‘Supplying good quality products, serving people with all my heart.’ (1978)

The design then started to resemble Western advertising: the colours became softer and the outlines of figures more gentle, particularly with the portrayal of women. More and more people were shown as wearing Western clothes or having Western haircuts. When I look at these posters and their slogans I can’t help but think of 1960s American TV commercials: the kind where you have a housewife in a yellow and white checkered apron telling us with a pearly-white smile, “You’ll stop paying the elbow tax when you start cleaning with Ajax!”

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-10
Unknown Artist, ‘Mobilize yourself to plant trees and flowers to beautify our environment.’ (1983)
chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-11
Unknown Artist, ‘Spring comes early for the diligent tiller’ (1987) Notice the Japanese brand of motorcycle…

But these new posters were still a form of propaganda; they still put the emphasis on the moral virtue of production as a way of contributing to the state, rather something for personal pleasure — seriously, have you ever been ‘mobilized’ to plant trees? Increasingly the posters came across as old-fashioned and lost their popularity. As the art market became less and less regulated by the government, artists moved on to develop their own form of expression, rather than the government’s.

This change made it possible for Wang to produce works towards the end of the 1980s which questioned the customary portrayal of Chairman Mao. He took images of the former leader and overlaid them with a grid of thick, black lines, substituting the normally warm reds for cold, bluish greys. He literally put up a barrier between Mao and the people, forcing viewers to take a new look at the image that had been regarded by so many as god-like.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-12
Wang Guangyi, ‘Mao Zedong: AO’ (Triptych) (1988) (150cm x 120cm x 3)

Even now, a huge portrait of Mao hangs over the main entrance to the Forbidden City in Tiananmen Square, and in the middle of the square (upsetting its feng shui) is his mausoleum, where you can see his embalmed body if you’re willing to queue for long enough. I stood in that queue for about two hours in the sweltering heat of August last year, and in the end, like everybody else, I only got to see Mao’s waxy body for ten seconds. And yet thousands of people do this every day. Inside the hall, the atmosphere is reverential, as though you’re visiting a church and you’re not allowed to talk, take photographs or have bags with you. It’s a bizarre set of contradictions: the government has distanced itself from Mao’s policies ever since his death and yet doesn’t go so far as to erase his image completely. Meanwhile, the people of China increasingly crave a capitalist lifestyle and yet they will come from all over the country to see Mao’s body. Wang Guangyi was brave to question Mao’s official portrayal only ten years after his death, when to do so could — and still can — potentially cause so much offence.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-13
The entrance to the Forbidden Palace at night.

Wang began his Great Criticism series of large-scale paintings in 1990, taking socialist and consumerist iconography and bluntly jamming them together. The works, painted in oil on canvas, are not as large as advertising billboards but by being on average two metres tall by two metres wide, they have a commanding presence. They are generally painted in the blocky style of the earlier posters from the 1960s, but sometimes the outlines appear more faded than the originals, implying the passing of time. At times Wang also changes the colour scheme altogether, using greens or blues, giving the images even more of a ‘Pop’ feel to them. He also covers the works in hundreds of little numbers in repetitive sequences, like barcodes or serial numbers — perhaps a reminder that his art is a product which needs cataloguing. In an interview with Charles Merewether, he explained that the central point he wants to express is “the ideological antagonism that exists between western culture and socialist ideology. The significance of this antagonism has more to do with issues in cultural studies than simply art in and of itself.”

For Wang Guangyi, growing up during the Cultural Revolution with such powerful poster design all around him meant that visual art and social issues were inseparable. He doesn’t look back on the Cultural Revolution as either a ‘good’ or ‘bad’ thing, but rather as something “meaningful” which provided a “visual modality” for him to work with. That visual modality has changed completely as China has become the last great untapped market for Western companies. Meanwhile, the younger generations of Chinese people crave Western goods and designer brands as much as their Japanese counterparts. By 1995, a nationwide consumer survey showed that Coca-Cola is the most famous and admired company in China.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-14
Wang Guangyi, ‘Great Criticism: Coca-Cola’ (1998) (200cm x 200cm)

Brand names such as Coca-Cola and Marlboro have become, as Wang puts it, “highly socialized” in China, and it is the materialism that they represent which carries the most significance, “because the term is almost revolutionary, at least in China. From as far back as I can remember, materialism and idealism were opposites, antonyms, even antagonistic.”

Materialism, or the desire for commercial success is no longer seen as contradictory to artistic merit, especially for Wang Guangyi. Born into a poor family, he initially fulfilled the cliché of being a struggling artist, but now, like many other artists of his generation, he has joined China’s growing class of nouveau riche. For Wang, the rich nations’ romanticization of the passionate but penniless artist was not something to aspire to; having experienced the reality of poverty for himself, he aimed not just to be an artist, but a rich artist. This seemed to work out rather well, since Chinese contemporary art is in high demand at the moment. More and more galleries introducing Chinese artists are popping up and while the value of the works increases all the time, it is still generally less expensive than Western art. 90% of buyers are from America, Europe or Japan.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-15
Wang Guangyi, ‘Great Criticism: Carlsberg’ (1996) (150cm x 150cm)

Apart from issues of disposable income, what is it about Chinese contemporary art that appeals to non-Chinese buyers? In Wang Guanyi’s case I suspect it’s because his paintings are open enough to interpretation to appeal to a broad range of art lovers. By putting together two sets of imagery that are instantly recognisable as Chinese and Western, they work at the most raw visual level: you don’t need to be an expert on China to understand what’s going on here. But the more people know about China, the more they can read into the work.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-16
Wang Guangyi, ‘Great Criticism: WTO’ (2001) (200cm x 200cm)

More recently, Wang has shifted the focus of some of the paintings from brand logos to the names of artists like Warhol and Beuys, who he says had a huge impact on him. Chinese artists have often faced the criticism that they are merely imitating the ideas and techniques of Western artists. I don’t think this accusation makes sense: it doesn’t matter what techniques Chinese artists use, they are addressing issues which face Chinese society. And given that Chinese society is ‘westernising’, isn’t it appropriate for them to refer to Western art and design?

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-17
Dashanzi

It remains to be seen what Wang Guangyi will do next and where contemporary Chinese art will go. The Chinese contemporary art scene essentially pivots around the semi-industrial area of Danshanzi in north-eastern Beijing and the Moganshan Road area of converted warehouses near Shanghai Station, but these communities of galleries, artists’ studios and shops are both at risk of corporate redevelopment.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-19

Moganshan Road. Old buildings surrounded by looming redevelopment.

chinese-pop-propaganda-poster-art-20
ShanghART Gallery

For the time being, with the Beijing Olympics in 2008 and the Shanghai World Expo in 2010, the Chinese government recognises that in order to be considered a world class host of international events, they need these cultural areas, so their future appears to be safe for the time being. But even if they should close down, there is no doubt that artists like Wang Guangyi will continue to find ways of showing their work and expressing their views about their rapidly changing society.

  • http://i5bala.blogspot.com Balakumar Muthu

    I could feel a biggest force in these posters…


    Balakumar Muthu
    http://i5bala.blogspot.com

  • http://www.mostwanted.com.au DingDong

    I need to goto beijing, can’t believe I haven’t been there.

  • Anonymous

    That wars so nice! I thouht it dlove hme za messerage.

  • http://www.stryder.com Ross

    Thank you for putting these works online.

  • http://www.chinesepropaganda.com You know who!

    Ping Mag always gets such quality comments… I’ll do my best to not lower the level…

    This was a pretty smart article putting the spotlight on people that make art for more than just pretty visuals and moreover in a land where freedom of expression is not written in the constitution (yet).
    Would love to hear more about the art scene in Beijing and Shanghai.
    pretty please Ping Mag!

  • Anonymous

    Actually, the Chinese constitution guarantees freedom of speech, press, religion, etc:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ConstitutionofthePeople’sRepublicofChina

    I guess it’s just not um…. followed very closely.

  • Zhe

    “Just not um… followed very closely”

    You mean like the United States? There, comic book artists are tried for obscenity, leading senators are calling for treason charges against the New York Times, and congress is gearing up for a constitutional amendment against flag “desecration.”

  • Pingback: Jet Grrl » Blog Archive » links for 2006-07-01

  • Pingback: newsBreaks.net » Wang Guangyi’s propaganda posters hawk capitalist wares

  • Pingback: Netlex News » Blog Archive » Wang Guangyi : chinese propaganda posters revisited

  • Pingback: Akkam’s Razor

  • Pingback: Collateral Damage » Blog Archive » Sparklers, snakes & salutes*

  • Commenting on Zhe

    Zhe, are you serious in trying to say that the two countries are similar in terms of their free speech? That is laughable.

  • http://www.go-sexshop.eu Sexshop, Sex shop,

    Thank you for putting these works online.
    I is under the impression
    thank

  • http://www.gomylove.cn/blog/user1/89/index.html lopez

    噢,中国的设计!

  • wzc

    What the most important thing in china is developing. Nothing could stop the aspiration of developing because china has suffered enough during the last 150years(from Opium War),and we clearly know it’s just a funning joke to talk about democracy and private right without a prosper country and its dominion. Ideology of capitalism world is going to change, it could not be stoped whether you like or not, it’s a trend of history,just like the global economy and capitalism taking place of the feudalism. However there is a long priod of time,maybe even after when we all die. So why not take a look at marxism and the new theory of china, if you can buy one in your democracy nation. sometimes i wonder how you think the highly developed alien in scientific films?do they still count everything on money?

  • Anonymous

    垃圾中国

  • shirley

    楼上的垃圾日本

  • Pingback: bestposterscheap.info » Blog Archive

  • Pingback: Bloredom » Best news of the week

  • Pingback: Carteles de la Revolución China « Karamade

  • http://GigantiCo.squarespace.com Chris Grayson

    I appreciate the depth of the stories on your site. Incidentally, I link you in my blog role at GigantiCo.

  • http://www.acarlarnakliyat.com nakliyat

    thanks for your subject. it is very important

  • Pingback: Chinese Pop Propaganda | RADIODELICATESSEN

  • Riding Lawn Mower Store

    Denver, Colorado.

  • http://www.easyfatlossinfo.com Easy Fat Loss Info

    Love this site, This is one of the best sites on how to loss weight,So if you are looking to loss weight and look great then you need to check this site out:

  • http://www.virtualblackswanmarketing.com Demand Lead Generation

    ~ If we could see the miracle of a single flower clearly, our whole life would change. ~

  • http://www.virtualblackswanmarketing.com You can Be capable of geting more Higher Public relations backlinks than all of your rivals, Find out precisely what your competitors do

    If you want to know more about Backlink Profit Monster REVIEW, is Backlink Profit Monster SCAM or Even The Real Deal? You’ve come to the right site.

  • http://www.yourpersonaldevelopmentandsuccess.com/ personal development
  • http://www.tuscanywind.com energie rinnovabili

    Turbine Idroelettriche

  • Free Traffic Referrals

    Everyday I learn something new and im loving it.

  • http://factoidz.com/how-to-tighten-sagging-skin-naturally/ Tighten sagging skin

    Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates.

  • http://loveforlifetime.com Love For A Lifetime

    I really loved your website, it was very informative. It is not always easy creating a website, I spend many hours on mine at love for a lifetime. Keep up the good work!

  • http://myweb-traffic.com Contact Strategy Marketing

    Great topic,I will post a link to this page on my blog.

  • http://tinyurl.com/3rakqyq Immediate Traffic For You

    Networking via the internet a most difficult and refreshing challenge.

  • http://myweb-traffic.com Pricing Strategy Marketing

    I thought it was some boring old post,it really compensated for my time.

  • http://www.stepstoplayingsoccer.com Soccer

    If u like soccer visit us!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • http://myweb-traffic.com/blog/ united health insurance providers

    i wish i could build a good blog like this..thanks

  • http://www.examplesviralmarketing.net/ Examples Viral Marketing

    I am a big fan of foreign exchange and finance so I find this topic very interesting. I always prefer to undertsand a new method of taking a look at it. Thanks for the information.

  • http://www.healthnaturalproductsdatabase.com/ Health Natural Products Database

    This article was attention-grabbing to read. I am glad to search out this put up as a result of I’m interested within the topic.

  • http://www.e-flucures.com Flu Cures

    I like your website,looking fora healther body.

  • http://mightysolos.info Get 125.000 visitors Free with Mighty Solos

    Owner Mighty Solos

  • http://www.jamondesalamanca.es Jamon Iberico

    Gran articulo. Somos seguidores vuestros desde hace tiempo y queriamos aprovechar este comentario para felicitaros por vuestro blog y por el trabajo que estais haciendo en los articulos…

  • http://www.jaspis.se smycken online

    very good. thank you

  • http://www.fashionlouboutinsale.com/ christian louboutin

    I really would like to learn more information about your business, what is it and why is it important.

  • http://www.ego-tank.ro tigara electronica ego tank

    Exetrmely helpful article, please write more. Team tigara electronica ego tank

  • http://forexwikipedia.blogspot.com/ forex wikipedia

    Free Indicateur,Free Expert Advisor,feedwikipedia,forex wikipedia.

  • http://www.realelixir.com อาหารเสริม

    ช่วย เสริมให้ผิวขาว กระจ่างใสทั่วร่างกาย ควบคุมการทำงานของเม็ดสีผิวให้เป็นปกติ ลดการเกิดฝ้า กระ จุดด่างดำ ต่อต้านอนุมูลอิสระ ปกป้องผิวและร่างกายจากมลภาวะเป็นพิษ ลดสารพิษตกค้างภายในร่างกาย

  • http://c-35.com Canon Black Friday

    Thank You FYI.

  • http://www.katavendo.com.br Kata-Vendo – Bons ventos para seus neg�cios

    Anuncie no Katavendo e usufrua DE TODOS OS BENEFICIOS OFERECIDOS, NO KATAVENDO voce encontra: anuncio, anuncios, anuncie, anunciar, classificado, classificados, classificados gratis, anuncios classificados gratis, imovel, imoveis, autos, automoveis, automovel, veiculos, carros, motos, celulares, video-games, computadores, dominios, cameras digitais, livros, quadinhos, revistas, cds, cd, dvds, DVD, hd, informatica, eletro-eletronicos, eletronicos, audio, video, decoracao, joias, relogios, esportes, lazer, negocios, filmadoras, videos, selos, moedas, ferramentas, antiguidades, raridades, oportunidades, promocoes, empregos, curriculos, servicos, artigos esportivos, empresas, produtos, vestuario, revistas, Sao Paulo, sp, Rio de Janeiro, rj, parana, pr, classificados, katavendo, kata-vendo, catavendo, cata-vendo, an�ncios, gr�tis, gratuitos, gratuitamente, empregos, oportunidades, comprar, vender.

  • http://www.triplejweb.com Diseño web madrid-Triple j web

    china, china, china.
    Thanks for share

  • http://sonynwzwalkman.info technology

    Check out our Cyber Monday deals on everything from cell phones with service to no-contract phones, unlocked phones, Bluetooth headsets, cases, chargers, and more

  • http://watchestimex.com Watches Timex

    Ladies Timex Watches

  • http://solusina.com/ toko jasa

    wow… is cool….

  • http://www.partaji.com Partaji.com – share the info …

    Partaji Admin

  • http://1weekcarinsurance.net Anonymous

    A few weeks ago my family and I went on vacation and had to rent a car. When at the car rental counter we were asked if we wanted to buy one day car insurance. Not knowing what 1 day car insurance was at the time time we figured we better be safe then sorry. So of course we did.

  • http://www.thevisayas.com The Visayas

    Thank you so much for this content, Im so lucky and glad that I found this website, Please keep this website going and I will keep

  • http://removingtattoosnaturally.com Removing Tattoos Naturally

    Your business sounds very interesting. It is great to have businesses that can contribute to so much to our society these days.

  • http://www.majalatouki.com المرأة

    I always visit your blog and retrieve everything you post here but I never commented but today when I saw this post, I couldn t stop myself from commenting here. Fantastic article!

  • http://www.yorumblog.com Laptop Özellikleri

    Thank you. I’ll sharing the post at my twitter.

  • http://www.imobiliare-video.com Real estate

    Imobiliare, vanzari case, vanzari apartamente, terenuri, craiova

  • http://www.stopitnow.gr ηλεκτρονικο τσιγαρο

    ηλεκτρονικο τσιγαρο,ego-T

  • http://www.temple-jewellery.com/ Temple Jewellery

    This piece of information is a gem for me, very helpful, really a great piece of writing, thanks for the effort made, really impressed.

  • http://www.titaniumvisa.net titanium visa

    This is very usefull tips

  • http://www.rcmb3140.com/ Rotaract Club

    This piece of information is really very helpful, i am pleased by the information provided here, will keep coming to check further, thanks.

  • http://www.hitbeats.de Deutsch Polnische Musik Band f�r Ihre Hochzeit, Feier, Geburtstag aus M�nster NRW.

    MOTET GbR- Band, DJs & S�nger f�r jeden Anla� & f�r jedes Budget.

  • http://whirlpoolwashers.org whirlpool washers

    Hi ….. I have information about Whirlpool washers, you should read them and get tips and tricks commersial business with Whirlpool washers.

  • http://www.programajuridico.com.br Software Juridico e Programa Juridico e CRM Juridico

    Software Juridico totalmente web para advogados, escritorios de advocacia e deptos Juridicos. Programa para advocacia

  • Polnische Band – Die deutsche und polnische Hochzeitsband aus M?nster NRW.

    polnische-band-hochzeit.motet.de

  • http://gunlukkiralikev.com.tr günlük kiralık ev

    Günlük kiralık villa fırsatlarımızı takip edin, beş yıldızlı otel konforunda, SPA, türk hamamı, açık ve kapalı havuz farklılığına 98 TL ye sahip olun

  • http://www.goadvertisetomillions.com advertise to millions

    Wow, how come it took me almost 4 years to find your website, I have been looking for something like this online for the pass four years,

  • http://www.renover.se Målare Stockholm

    Another useful article again. Thanks.

  • http://www.stopitnow.gr ηλεκτρονικο τριγαρο

    stopitnow site

  • ToowoombaMusic

    Well said – Very good ideas and well informed